Paper 2024/879

Consistency-or-Die: Consistency for Key Transparency

Abstract

This paper proposes a new consistency protocol that protects a key transparency log against split-view attacks and - contrary to all previous work - does not to rely on small committees of known external auditors, or out-of-band channels, or blockchains (full broadcast systems). Our approach is to use a mechanism for cryptographically selecting a small committee of random and initially undisclosed users, which are then tasked to endorse the current view of the log. The name of our protocol, Consistency-or-Die (CoD), reflects that users are guaranteed to know if they are in a consistent state or not, and upon spotting an inconsistency in the key transparency log, users stop using this resource and become inactive (die). CoD relies on well-established cryptographic building blocks, such as verifiable random functions and key-evolving signatures, for which lightweight constructions exist. We provide a novel statistical analysis for identifying optimal quorum sizes (minimal number of endorsers for a view) for various security levels and percentages of malicious users. Our experiments support that CoD is practical and can run in the background on mid-tier smart phones, for large-scale systems with billions of users.