Paper 2026/1144

On the Impossibility of SNARGs with Short CRS (or: Revisiting Gentry-Wichs Barrier in the Non-adaptive Setting)

Abstract

We study the inherent barriers to constructing non-adaptively sound succinct non-interactive arguments (SNARGs) for NP with a CRS whose length is sublinear in the witness length. Our results cover both the standard SNARGs and SNARGs with an additional updatable feature (i.e. incrementally verifiable computation for NP). - For updatable SNARGs, we show a black-box separation from falsifiable assumptions for uniform polynomial-time reductions, assuming sub-exponential hardness of learning with error. - For general SNARGs, we show a black-box separation from falsifiable assumptions for non-uniform polynomial-time reductions that only non-adaptively make an instance-size-independent number of queries to the adversary, assuming the existence of sub-exponentially secure super-bit generators. We observe that all known SNARG constructions from polynomial hardness of standard assumptions have 1-query soundness reductions. Thus, our result complements existing constructions. Previously, the seminal work [Gentry-Wichs, STOC'11] showed a black-box separation of SNARGs from falsifiable assumptions in the adaptive soundness setting. We explore whether any barriers exist in the non-adaptive setting. To obtain our result, we derive a simulation lemma for unbounded polynomial-length auxiliary inputs assuming super-bit generators.