Paper 2025/945

Quantum Security Analysis of the Key-Alternating Ciphers

Abstract

In this work, we study the quantum security of key-alternating ciphers (KAC), a natural multi-round generalization of the Even–Mansour (EM) cipher underlying many block cipher constructions, including AES. While the classical security of KAC and the quantum security of the $1$-round KAC (i.e. Even-Mansour) cipher are well understood, the quantum resistance of multi-round KAC remains largely unexplored. We focus on the $2$-round KAC construction, defined using public $n$-bit permutations $P_1$, $P_2$ and keys $k_0$, $k_1$, and $k_2$ as $E(x) = P_2(P_1(x \oplus k_0) \oplus k_1) \oplus k_2.$ Our main contributions are as follows: 1. Quantum Lower Bounds. We provide the first formal analysis showing that a $2$-round KAC is quantum-secure in both the $Q1$ and $Q2$ models. Specifically, in the $Q1$ model, a (non-adaptive) adversary must make at least $2^{2n/5}$ quantum queries to the public permutations and at least $2^{2n/5}$ classical queries to the cipher in order to distinguish it from a random permutation (in contrast to the classical lower bound of $2^{2n/3}$ queries). As a corollary, we show that in the $Q2$ model, a (non-adaptive) adversary requires $2^{n/4}$ quantum queries. To achieve such a result, we employ the quantum hybrid method along with recently proposed lifting theorems in the ideal cipher and random permutation oracle model. 2. Quantum Key-Recovery Attack. We give the first nontrivial quantum key-recovery attack on multi-round KAC in the $Q1$ model where the adversary has quantum access to all of the public permutations. Our quantum attack applies to any $t$-round KAC and achieves quantum query complexity $O(2^{\alpha n})$, where $\alpha = \frac{t(t+1)}{(t+1)^2 + 1}$, improving over the best known classical bound of $O(2^{\alpha' n})$, where $\alpha' = \frac{t}{t+1}$, from Bogdanov et al. (EUROCRYPT 2012). The attack leverages a novel application of quantum walk algorithms specifically adapted to the KAC structure. 3. The $Q1^*$ Model. To bridge the classical and $Q1$ settings, we introduce the $Q1^*$, in which the adversary has quantum superposition access to at most one permutation. This model is crucial for our $Q1$ lower bound and supports similar key-recovery attacks to Q1, using fewer quantum resources. We believe $Q1^*$ is of independent interest.