Paper 2025/2054

Optimal Proximity Gaps for Subspace-Design Codes and (Random) Reed-Solomon Codes

Abstract

Reed-Solomon (RS) codes were recently shown to exhibit an intriguing $\textit{proximity gap}$ phenomenon. Specifically, given a collection of strings with some algebraic structure (such as belonging to a line or affine space), either all of them are $\delta$-close to RS codewords, or most of them are $\delta$-far from the code. Here $\delta$ is the proximity parameter which can be taken to be the Johnson radius $1-\sqrt{R}$ of the RS code ($R$ being the code rate), matching its best known list-decodability. Proximity gaps play a crucial role in the soundness analysis of Interactive Oracle Proof (IOP) protocols used in Succinct Non-Interactive Arguments of Knowledge (SNARKs) and the resulting proof sizes. Proving proximity gaps beyond the Johnson radius, and in particular approaching $1-R$ (which is best possible), has been posed multiple times as a challenge with significant practical consequences to the efficiency of SNARKs. Here we prove that variants of RS codes, such as folded RS codes and univariate multiplicity codes, indeed have proximity gaps for $\delta$ approaching $1-R$. The result applies more generally to codes with a certain subspace-design property. Our proof hinges on a clean property we abstract called line (or more generally curve) decodability, which we establish leveraging and adapting techniques from recent progress on list-decoding such codes. Importantly, our analysis avoids the heavy algebraic machinery used in previous works, and requires a field size only linear in the block length. The behavior of subspace-design codes w.r.t ``local properties'' has recently been shown to be similar to random linear codes and random RS codes (where the evaluation points are chosen at random from the underlying field). We identify a local property that implies curve decodability, and thus also proximity gaps, and thereby conclude that random linear and random RS codes also exhibit proximity gaps up to the $1-R$ bound. Our results also establish the stronger (mutual) correlated agreement property which implies proximity gaps. Additionally, we also a show a $\textit{slacked}$ proximity gap theorem for constant-sized fields using AEL-based constructions and local property techniques.