Paper 2024/598

Decryption Indistinguishability under Chosen Control Flow

Abstract

Security proofs for cryptographic primitives typically assume operations are executed in the correct sequence; however, insecure implementations or software-level attacks can disrupt control flows, potentially invalidating these guarantees. To address this issue, we introduce a new security notion, IND-CFA, which formalizes decryption security in the presence of adversarially controlled execution flows. Using this notion, we investigate the control flows under which a cryptographic scheme remains secure, providing insights into secure implementation practices. We revisit the Encrypt-then-MAC paradigm, underscoring the crucial role of operation sequencing in ensuring the security of authenticated encryption schemes built using this method. Additionally, we provide a detailed analysis of the Encode-then-Encipher (EtE) paradigm, a widely adopted approach for constructing robust AE schemes, revealing its vulnerability to adversarial control flows that can enable attackers to infer low-entropy values in the presence of multiple failure conditions.