Cryptology ePrint Archive: Report 2005/250

The topology of covert conflict

Shishir Nagaraja, Ross Anderson

Abstract: Often an attacker tries to disconnect a network by destroying nodes or edges, while the defender counters using various resilience mechanisms. Examples include a music industry body attempting to close down a peer-to-peer file-sharing network; medics attempting to halt the spread of an infectious disease by selective vaccination; and a police agency trying to decapitate a terrorist organisation. Albert, Jeong and Barabasi famously analysed the static case, and showed that vertex-order attacks are effective against scale-free networks. We extend this work to the dynamic case by developing a framework based on evolutionary game theory to explore the interaction of attack and defence strategies. We show, first, that naive defences don't work against vertex-order attack; second, that defences based on simple redundancy don't work much better, but that defences based on cliques work well; third, that attacks based on centrality work better against clique defences than vertex-order attacks do; and fourth, that defences based on complex strategies such as delegation plus clique resist centrality attacks better than simple clique defences. Our models thus build a bridge between network analysis and evolutionary game theory, and provide a framework for analysing defence and attack in networks where topology matters. They suggest definitions of efficiency of attack and defence, and may even explain the evolution of insurgent organisations from networks of cells to a more virtual leadership that facilitates operations rather than directing them. Finally, we draw some conclusions and present possible directions for future research.

Category / Keywords: applications / anonymity, information hiding, terrorism, scale-free networks, complex networks, evolutionary game theory, resilience, conflict

Publication Info: Computer Laboratory, Technical Report 637, University of Cambridge

Date: received 30 Jul 2005, last revised 1 Aug 2005

Contact author: sn275 at cam ac uk

Available format(s): PDF | BibTeX Citation


Version: 20050801:095644 (All versions of this report)

Short URL:

[ Cryptology ePrint archive ]