Paper 2024/929

Combining Outputs of a Random Permutation: New Constructions and Tight Security Bounds by Fourier Analysis

Abstract

We consider constructions that combine outputs of a single permutation $\pi:\{0,1\}^n \rightarrow \{0,1\}^n$ using a public function. These are popular constructions for achieving security beyond the birthday bound when implementing a pseudorandom function using a block cipher (i.e., a pseudorandom permutation). One of the best-known constructions (denoted SXoP$[2,n]$) XORs the outputs of 2 domain-separated calls to $\pi$. Modeling $\pi$ as a uniformly chosen permutation, several previous works proved a tight information-theoretic indistinguishability bound for SXoP$[2,n]$ of about $q/2^{n}$, where $q$ is the number of queries. On the other hand, tight bounds are unknown for the generalized variant (denoted SXoP$[r,n]$) which XORs the outputs of $r>2$ domain-separated calls to a uniform permutation. In this paper, we obtain two results. Our first result improves the known bounds for SXoP$[r,n]$ for all (constant) $r \geq 3$ (assuming $q \leq O(2^n/r)$ is not too large) in both the single-user and multi-user settings. In particular, for $q=3$, our bound is about $\sqrt{u}q_{\max}/2^{2.5n}$ (where $u$ is the number of users and $q_{\max}$ is the maximal number of queries per user), improving the best-known previous result by a factor of at least $2^n$. For odd $r$, our bounds are tight for $q > 2^{n/2}$, as they match known attacks. For even $r$, we prove that our single-user bounds are tight by providing matching attacks. Our second and main result is divided into two parts. First, we devise a family of constructions that output $n$ bits by efficiently combining outputs of 2 calls to a permutation on $\{0,1\}^n$, and achieve multi-user security of about $\sqrt{u} q_{\max}/2^{1.5n}$. Then, inspired by the CENC construction of Iwata [FSE'06], we further extend this family to output $2n$ bits by efficiently combining outputs of 3 calls to a permutation on $\{0,1\}^n$. The extended construction has similar multi-user security of $\sqrt{u} q_{\max}/2^{1.5n}$. The new single-user ($u=1$) bounds of $q/2^{1.5n}$ for both families should be contrasted with the previously best-known bounds of $q/2^n$, obtained by the comparable constructions of SXoP$[2,n]$ and CENC. All of our bounds are proved by Fourier analysis, extending the provable security toolkit in this domain in multiple ways.