Cryptology ePrint Archive: Report 2016/644

How to Backdoor Diffie-Hellman

David Wong

Abstract: Lately, several backdoors in cryptographic constructions, protocols and implementations have been surfacing in the wild: Dual-EC in RSA's B-Safe product, a modified Dual-EC in Juniper's operating system ScreenOS and a non-prime modulus in the open-source tool socat. Many papers have already discussed the fragility of cryptographic constructions not using nothing-up-my-sleeve numbers, as well as how such numbers can be safely picked. However, the question of how to introduce a backdoor in an already secure, safe and easy to audit implementation has so far rarely been researched (in the public). We present a new way of building a Nobody-But-Us (NOBUS) Diffie-Hellman backdoor by using a composite modulus with a smooth order. We then explain how we were able to implement a proof of concept with Socat and OpenSSL in order to exploit our backdoor on the TLS protocol.

Update (December 2016): Dorey et al. have pointed an attack on our first contribution, as well as an improvement for the exploitation of our second contribution. This work has been updated to reflect these advances.

Category / Keywords: public-key cryptography / Diffie-Hellman, Ephemeral, DHE, NOBUS, Backdoor, Discrete Logarithm, Small Subgroup Attack, Pohlig-Hellman, Pollard Rho, Factorization, Pollard's p-1, ECM, Dual-EC, Juniper, socat

Date: received 21 Jun 2016, last revised 27 Dec 2016

Contact author: moi at davidwong fr

Available format(s): PDF | BibTeX Citation

Note: paper

has broken a section of this paper, and improved another one.

Version: 20161227:183120 (All versions of this report)

Short URL:

Discussion forum: Show discussion | Start new discussion

[ Cryptology ePrint archive ]