Paper 2016/418

Shorter Circuit Obfuscation in Challenging Security Models

Zvika Brakerski and Or Dagmi

Abstract

The study of program obfuscation is seeing great progress in recent years, which is crucially attributed to the introduction of graded encoding schemes by Garg, Gentry and Halevi (Eurocrypt 2013). In such schemes, elements of a ring can be encoded such that the content of the encoding is hidden, but restricted algebraic manipulations, followed by zero-testing, can be performed publicly. This primitive currently underlies all known constructions of general-purpose obfuscators. However, the security properties of the current candidate graded encoding schemes are not well understood, and new attacks frequently introduced. It is therefore important to assume as little as possible about the security of the graded encoding scheme, and use as conservative security models as possible. This often comes at a cost of reducing the efficiency or the functionality of the obfuscator. In this work, we present a candidate obfuscator, based on composite-order graded encoding schemes, which obfuscates circuits directly a la Zimmerman (Eurocrypt 2015) and Applebaum-Brakerski (TCC 2015). Our construction requires a graded encoding scheme with only $$ ``plaintext slots'' (= sub-rings of the underlying ring), which is directly related to the size and complexity of the obfuscated program. We prove that our obfuscator is superior to previous works in two different security models. 1. We prove that our obfuscator is indistinguishability-secure (iO) in the \emph{Unique Representation Generic Graded Encoding} model. Previous works either required a composite-order scheme with polynomially many slots, or were provable in a milder security model. This immediately translates to a polynomial improvement in efficiency, and shows that improved security does not come at the cost of efficiency in this case. 2. Following Badrinarayanan et al.\ (Eurocrypt 2016), we consider a model where finding any ``non-trivial'' encoding of zero breaks the security of the encoding scheme. We show that, perhaps surprisingly, secure obfuscation is possible in this model even for some classes of \emph{non-evasive functions} (for example, any class of conjunctions). We define the property required of the function class, formulate an appropriate (generic) security model, and prove that our aforementioned obfuscator is virtual-black-box (VBB) secure in this model.