Cryptology ePrint Archive: Report 2013/555
Key Exchange with Unilateral Authentication: Composable Security Definition and Modular Protocol Design
Ueli Maurer and Björn Tackmann and Sandro Coretti
Abstract: Key exchange with unilateral authentication (short: unilateral key exchange)
is an important primitive in practical security protocols; a prime example is
the widely deployed TLS protocol, which is usually run in this mode.
Unilateral key-exchange protocols are employed in a client-server setting
where only the server has a certified public key. The client is then
authenticated by sending credentials via a connection that is secured with the
key obtained from the protocol. Somewhat surprisingly and despite its
importance in practical scenarios, this type of key exchange has received
relatively little attention in the cryptographic literature compared to the
type with mutual authentication.
In this work, we follow the constructive cryptography paradigm of Maurer and
Renner (ICS 2011) to obtain a (composable) security definition for
key-exchange protocols with unilateral authentication: We describe a
"unilateral key" resource and require from a key-exchange protocol that it
constructs this resource in a scenario where only the server is authenticated.
One main advantage of this approach is that it comes with strong composition
guarantees: Any higher-level protocol proven secure with respect to the
unilateral key resource remains secure if the key is obtained using a secure
unilateral key-exchange protocol.
We then describe a simple protocol based on any CPA-secure KEM and prove that
it constructs a unilateral key (previous protocols in this setting relied on a
CCA-secure KEM). The protocol design and our security analysis are fully
modular and allow to replace a sub-protocol $\pi$ by a different sub-protocol
$\pi'$ by only proving security of the sub-protocol $\pi'$; the composition
theorem immediately guarantees that the security of the modified full protocol
is maintained. In particular, one can replace the KEM by a sub-protocol based
on Diffie-Hellman, obtaining a protocol that is similar to the A-DHKE protocol
proposed by Shoup. Moreover, our analysis is simpler because the actual
key-exchange part of the protocol can be analyzed in a simple three-party
setting; we show that the extension to the multi-party setting follows
Compared to the TLS handshake protocol, the "de facto" standard for unilateral
key exchange on the Internet, our protocol is more efficient (only two
messages) and is based on weaker assumptions.
Category / Keywords: public-key cryptography / key exchange, constructive cryptography
Date: received 3 Sep 2013, last revised 23 Jan 2014
Contact author: bjoernt at inf ethz ch
Available format(s): PDF | BibTeX Citation
Note: References and minor corrections.
Version: 20140123:122005 (All versions of this report)
Discussion forum: Show discussion | Start new discussion
[ Cryptology ePrint archive ]