Paper 2009/037

Common Modulus Attacks on Small Private Exponent RSA and Some Fast Variants (in Practice)

M. Jason Hinek and Charles C. Y. Lam

Abstract

In this work we re-examine two common modulus attacks on RSA. First, we show that Guo's continued fraction attack works much better in practice than previously expected. Given three instances of RSA with a common modulus $N$ and private exponents each smaller than $N^{0.33}$ the attack can factor the modulus about $93\mathrm{\%}$ of the time in practice. The success rate of the attack can be increased up to almost $100\mathrm{\%}$ by including a relatively small exhaustive search. Next, we consider Howgrave-Graham and Seifert's lattice-based attack and show that a second necessary condition for the attack exists that limits the bounds (beyond the original bounds) once $n\ge 7$ instances of RSA are used. In particular, by construction, the attack can only succeed when the private exponents are each smaller than $$, given sufficiently many instances, instead of the original bound of $$. In addition, we also consider the effectiveness of the attacks when mounted against multi-prime RSA and Tagaki's variant of RSA. For multi-prime RSA, we show three (or more) instances with a common modulus and private exponents smaller than $$ is unsafe. For Takagi's variant, we show that three or more instances with a common modulus $$ is unsafe when all the private exponents are smaller than $$. The results, for both variants, is obtained using Guo's method and are successful almost always with the inclusion of a small exhaustive search. When only two instances are available, Howgrave-Graham and Seifert's attack can be mounted on multi-prime RSA when the private exponents are smaller than $$ when there are $$ primes in the modulus.