Paper 2008/113

Open Source Is Not Enough. Attacking the EC-package of Bouncycastle version 1.x_132

Daniel Mall and Qing Zhong

Abstract

BouncyCastle is an open source Crypto provider written in Java which supplies classes for Elliptic Curve Cryptography (ECC). We have found a flaw in the class ECPoint resulting from an unhappy interaction of elementary algorithms. We show how to exploit this flaw to a real world attack, e.g., on the encryption scheme ECIES. BouncyCastle has since fixed this flaw (version 1.x_133 and higher) but all older versions remain highly vulnerable to an active attacker and the attack shows a certain vulnerability of the involved validation algorithms.